Taraia Object Expedition on Nikumaroro Island determines the identity of the visual anomaly: it’s not wreckage of Amelia Earhart’s lost Electra aircraft
Drafted in Tarawa after our return from Nikumaroro
Transcript
Hello, and welcome to another special edition of Audio News from Archaeologica, with the latest from the Taraia Object Expedition. I’m Laura Kennedy, and this episode covers the period from October 18 through the 24th. This is the week we finally answered the question that brought us to the remote island of Nikumaroro. Is the Taraia Object, a feature in the island’s lagoon, the wreckage of the Lockheed Electra that Amelia Earhart was flying when she vanished in 1937? Here’s how we found out.
When we last spoke, rough seas had kept our team aboard the ship LC Marin Mainiku for three frustrating days. On the morning of October 18, we woke to a calmer sea and got the word that it was safe to go ashore.
My father, the expedition leader, had split us into two groups. The first included the people with the most urgent work: marine archaeologists Michael Krivor and Will Wilson, our technology team of Sirisha and me, and two of our filmmakers. We expected to find our camp in shambles after the storms. To our relief, the shelter at the Blasted Channel, our landing point on the reef, was untouched. The one at Club Fred, our launch spot on the lagoon shore, had simply tipped over. Our two aluminum boats were brimming with rainwater, so we tipped them up to drain, and then we all crossed the lagoon together.
Our field station on the Taraia sand spit had taken a beating. One canopy shelter was destroyed, and the others were blown over. The I-Kiribati members of the ship’s crew went straight to work. They tied the shelters together, added new guy lines and heavy stakes, and anchored every corner with sandbags. Our gear under the tarps had stayed safe and dry.
Our first order of business was the magnetic anomaly. Michael and Will had detected it four days earlier with their magnetometer, an instrument that senses buried iron and steel. With a hand-held instrument, Will tracked it down right at the edge of the beach, almost out of the water. Crew members helped dig, and the ship’s second engineer, Borau, helped coax a stubborn water pump into action. Then Michael and Will used a water jet to wash away the sediment.
By day’s end, they had their answer: an iron pipe about 60 centimeters long and three centimeters across, crusted with what looked like coral. That pipe fully explained the magnetic signal. How it got there remains a mystery, but it clearly had nothing to do with the Electra.
That brought us to the main event. Michael and Will began hydroprobing the lagoon floor at the Taraia Object site. That means pushing a long metal rod into the bottom at one-meter intervals to measure the depth of the water and the thickness of the soft sediment. Archaeologist Philippa Jorissen recorded the measurements as they worked along a series of lines, or transects, across the site.
By the end of the first day, a clear picture was emerging. The soft sediment lies on top of a firm layer of coarse coral gravel, which our probes struck instead of an airplane fuselage. On our final morning on the island, October 19, Michael and Will completed the probing, and the data confirmed it. Whatever made the Taraia Object, there is no buried airplane there.
So what did the satellites see? The evidence now points to a natural explanation. When Tropical Cyclone Pam swept through the region in 2015, its storm surge apparently tore up trees and other forest vegetation and piled them in the lagoon. That pile is what appeared in the satellite images, in a shape that could have been an aircraft fuselage and tail. Over the years since, it has mostly washed away or broken down.
What remains is the tree remnant we found on our first day ashore and nicknamed the “Y Object.” When we compared it with a drone image of the sand spit taken by our colleague David Pearson, the Y Object sat exactly where a dark triangle appears in a satellite image from April 2024. So the Taraia Object is not Amelia Earhart’s Electra. It was a cluster of storm-tossed trees. Not a single tree, mind you, but a complex of debris.
This is not the answer we hoped for. However, finding answers is what archaeology is for, and we now have one, backed by careful fieldwork and solid data. My father is satisfied to put this question to rest, so that the search for Earhart’s aircraft or other “smoking-gun” evidence can move on.
While all this was going on, Philippa and her assistants finished surveying the beach, pushing through vegetation made thick by heavy rains. Sirisha and I completed the technology station, with a Starlink internet connection, a solar power system, a weather station, and a security camera. They’re set on the highest ground nearby, with a sandbag berm to break incoming waves. They’re designed to keep sending us data for a year.
We did have to give up on one instrument, a water level sensor. The lagoon bottom there was so soft that nothing would hold its housing upright. Our diver Ella Van Cleave and the crew tried everything, including a wooden stand cut from a dead tree. In the end, I concluded that the design just wouldn’t work in that spot, and we packed it away.
On October 19, we cleaned up the site completely and carried everything back across the island. Four crew members set out to bring our aluminum boats around through the reef passage, while the rest of us had lunch near the Blasted Channel. A few of us swam in the channel, which teems with fish. But the boats didn’t come. They had left the lagoon too late, after the tide had dropped. Eventually, many of us waded out, lightened the loads, and pushed the boats across the reef by hand. It was tough going, but we made it back to the ship by about five o’clock.
On October 20, as we sailed for Tarawa, Kiribati’s capital, people finally rested. My father spent the day thinking about what comes next. The expedition had built real momentum, and the response from the public has been warm, even with our result. He met with the archaeology team to sketch out ideas for a possible return to Nikumaroro in 2027.
The plan has three parts. The first is a remote sensing survey of the lagoon between the Taraia Peninsula and the Tatiman Passage, where aerial photographs taken by a New Zealand survey in 1938 show an anomaly that could be the Electra. The second is test excavations at a site called Camp Zero, to see if Earhart and her navigator, Fred Noonan, may have camped there. The third is a gamma ray survey of the island’s colonial village, searching for cockpit instruments, painted with radioactive radium, that villagers might have collected. The team is enthusiastic, though much must happen first before this tentative plan can become reality.
On October 21, I led a team that emptied our shipping container onto the deck, sorted everything, and repacked it. That afternoon, the ship’s crew hosted a barbecue on the foredeck, cooking over a burn barrel. There was music, dancing, and karaoke. My father and Steve Schultz gave gifts to every crew member and our three I-Kiribati team members. It was a joyful celebration of the friendship that has grown between our team and the crew.
The next afternoon, we were treated to the most magnificent rainbow any of us had ever seen. It was a full double rainbow, with the main arc complete from end to end, brilliant and perfect, appearing to plunge right into the sea. Could it be a good omen?
On October 24, our last day at sea, we reached Tarawa lagoon around 11 at night. Most of us had already taken down our bed tents, ready to go ashore. Then word came that we did not have permission to land by small boat in the dark. So we spent one more night aboard, most of us sleeping on mattresses under the stars. Philippa had wisely kept her tent up.
We’ll go ashore at daybreak. Stay tuned to Audio News from Archaeologica for the final chapter of the Taraia Object Expedition. From Tarawa, this is Laura Kennedy.
